May 2016 News
CTE Math Faculty Liaison
Paul Kates

Topics

Teaching Excellence Awards

Early Student Feedback - Well Before Course Evaluations

Feedback from students doesn't have to wait until the end-of-term course evaluations. Getting feedback early and often in a course allows you to build on what's working and make changes towards what can work better, all in time to have an impact on your students.

Asking students at the start of the term about their expectations for the course, the lectures, the textbook even their own work habits can give you an insight into why your students are in your course and let you address expectations immediately should they be out-of-line with the way the course is going to be run.

Eric Mazur in his book Peer Instruction gives a start-of-term "Introductory Questionnaire" to his Physics class where he asks

(This and the following set of questions are attributed to Prof James Sethian, Department of Mathematics, University of California at Berkeley.)

With the answers in hand he addresses each of the questions in class - supporting and encouraging his students and expanding on student answers with his own goals for the class:

I want the material we cover to be useful to you beyond the exam. I want you to become good critical and analytical thinkers, able to tackle not just familiar problems but also unknown new problems or questions. Not only to plug numbers into equations but able to develop new models and theories, to make qualified assumptions, and then use those models and assumptions to break new ground in science and technology.

He also has the opportunity to address student expectations, realigning and influencing those expectations about the lectures, text and workload.

He gives a sample reply to all the questions above (ask me for a copy), but here I'll only quote the answer to the question
What do you expect the lectures to do for you?

There were many very thoughtful responses to this question, but I did encounter a number of misunderstandings about the lectures that I should address to avoid falling short of your expectations. The most serious misconception I encountered is that the lectures will present and explain the fundamental concepts, while the book will clarify the ideas presented in the lecture. This is not what is going to happen. You will be reading the material before coming to class. The book will introduce the basic terminology and definitions, hopefully raise some questions, perhaps even confuse you a little ("to wonder is to begin to understand"). The lectures are intended to challenge your thinking and thereby help you assess your understanding of the concepts you read about, to further and deepen your understanding of these concepts, to stimulate and inspire you, and to show you how things "fit together." The book will then provide further reference. In addition it will be a source for questions and problems.
Some of you expect to practice problem-solving in lecture, but problem-solving is not the main focus of this class. I want you to understand things, not just be able to "plug and chug." This is clearly reflected in the way you will be tested - take a good look at the exams in the back of the syllabus. Close to half of the questions on each exam are not the traditional, quantitative problems you may have seen before. The solutions to many of these don't involve even a single equation. Rest assured, the sections and homework assignments will offer ample opportunity to sharpen your traditional problem-solving skills. The lectures are meant to stimulate your thinking, to further your basic understanding. I guarantee that a better understanding of the concepts will improve your problem-solving abilities, whereas the reverse is not necessarily true. Here is what I think of some other answers given: ...

After a month Prof. Mazur uses the following questionnaire to gauge how students are settling in to the course. This is another early opportunity to address concerns, misunderstandings and expectations.

If you have your own in-course questionnaire and want to share it I'd be happy to post it along with any comments you care to include in a future edition of this page.

To read more about the topic of student feedback take a look at the following:

To see a wide range of questions asked in feedback questionnaires, take a look at this question collection from many schools made available Smith College Sherrerd Center for Teaching & Learning.

There is a Survey tool in LEARN to make questionnaires like those above. Students can answer online and anonymously.

CTE Learning/Teaching Events in Spring 2016

Faculty and staff courses at CTE:

Grad students also have a number of courses available from CTE.

CTE also has a growing collection of teaching stories from UW faculty members and new posts to the CTE blog site.

LEARN System Topics in Spring 2016

Classroom Lecture Recording and Observation

Interested in seeing how you teach from a student's point-of-view?
Book a time for a video recording and observation of one of your lectures. The lecture recording and feedback is shared only with the lecturer. Email pkates@uwaterloo.ca for arrangements.

CTE LITE Grant Information

Learning Innovation and Teaching Enhancement (LITE) grants deadlines:

Visit the application page for more information and the projects page for details on past and current grants.

LEARN, MapleTA, Clickers, ...

If you have any questions about using the course management system LEARN, the MapleTA assessment system, or want to try teaching with clickers in your classroom then please get in touch with me.

Previous post topics

From the February 2016 post:


Paul Kates
Mathematics Faculty CTE Liaison
pkates@uwaterloo.ca, x37047
Last modification date: Wed May 11 15:27:07 2016.
url: http://www.math.uwaterloo.ca/~pkates/CTE/events/may-2016.html